The Pricks In The Helium.com Balloon

71

By Randy Godwin

Freelancers Beware

There are many content sites on the internet to test your mettle as a writer. Some are fairly open about the goings on and you know what to expect. But as in any business, there are always some who take advantage of the hard work of others. I found out the hard way about the business of writing online. My first experience was at a site called Helium.com . It seemed like a cool site and the members were so helpful to newcomers like me. It seemed easy to write articles which ranked high enough to gain writing stars and I was having a blast for a while.

Then I started noticing things which made me uncomfortable. I began reading some of the articles which were rated #1 in a title group. One author would write complete paragraphs without a comma or period throughout and the spelling was horrible. This writer had many highly rated articles in his portfolio, just like the first one I found. I soon found this to be normal as others reported the same findings. I began reading the forums to see if I were the only one noticing these anomalies in the rating system. I was not alone.

I was informed any member can rate an article up or down if they had written in a channel in which the subject of the article was included. Even those who wrote terrible articles had the same rating power as someone who had expertise on the subject, or those who wrote grammatically correct, correctly spelled articles. Boy was I depressed! “This is the wave of the future” one pompous steward told me “if this article was chosen by the masses, then this what they want.” I was even more depressed!

Down, Down, Down

When the Pricks are too numerous, the balloon goes down
See all 4 photos
When the Pricks are too numerous, the balloon goes down

This Helium Is Not Odorless-It Stinks

I began to notice when other members mentioned the same problems I had encountered on the forums that the same stewards would rally around the Helium flagpole and dismiss or make light of the questioner. If anyone complained about an article rated above theirs, no matter how terrible the #1 article was, the complainer would be labeled as a “sour grapes” member by the same group of stewards. They became know as “Helium Cheerleaders.”

When I joined the site stewards were touted as “unpaid volunteers” helping the Helium staff by overseeing certain channels and sub-channels. They supposedly had no more control over articles than the common members. They didn’t even have to be experienced or particularly knowledgeable in the channel or sub-channel they were stewarding. Of course we common members didn’t know this piece of information, along with many more not-so-well-kept secrets. In short, Helium staff lies a lot. Not only the staff but the stewards too. Not all of them, as some the other stewards and subs were not aware of the special treatment of some elite stewards.

These specially chosen stewards were getting paid and still claimed to be volunteers. I confronted Helium about this by contacting Barbara Whitlock and exchanging many emails back and forth. “Like pulling teeth” as my dad would say about getting a straight answer. I knew it was true by the way she dodged and ducked the questions. She finally admitted it was a “trial” program and some stewards were receiving a small recompense for their work while others got nothing.

The stewards vilified me when I announced all of the stewards were not unpaid volunteers. I received copies of the stewards private forum posts calling me names and generally slamming me. Ms Whitlock also posted how the stews were heroes for treating me badly and threw in a few punches herself. Of course they didn’t know I was being fed the posts. But I was not through yet.

These Clowns Aren't Funny!

Stewards or Just Stooges?

You see, the stewards do have privileges the common members do not.  They can rate in any channel they choose.  If they write to a title about flower gardening they can keep choosing the sub channel until they can rate their closest competition down or their friend’s article up.  It only takes a few rejected leaps to refuse an edit to a writer, especially important in the so called writing contests.  Leaping at the last minute usually decides the winners of the contests, not the content.  Coincidentally, stewards win a good share of these contests.

The writing contests are a joke, of course.  It is simply a leapfrog contest by those who know how to game the system.  The stewards can choose any channel they please to rate in, not just those they have written in and not random articles.  Since it only takes three or four rejections to prohibit a leap from being accepted, the steward can effectively eliminate the competition for top ranking.  The main staff members and stews say this doesn’t happen, but they cannot be trusted as I have shown. 

Some of the stewards are “pieces of work” when it comes to quelling any dissent from the membership.  It’s easy to pick which of them are “company people.”  Let a member ask a question concerning some new rule or policy change and they swarm on the “complainer” like flies on road kill.  Especially the community board administrator.  I really owe this silly little man a debt of gratitude.  His statements and excuses were so ridiculous to me that he was the reason I began to smell a rat, or rather a pack of them.

Honest Answers At Helium? Not So Far!

Another Name For Helium.com
Another Name For Helium.com

Presidents, Preachers, and PMS

This mail-order reverend/shaman/braggart deleted my post calling me a liar in the process. I asked him to point out exactly where I lied in my statement. He emailed me saying he couldn’t recover the deleted post once it was gone. He loves to use stupid analogies to appear as a knowledgeable sincere helper but has put his foot in his mouth a number of times and had to delete his own ramblings. He once compared the writers to Nazis and the stewards to the allies. He got a few days off for that one. If a company is so hard up as to use this guy to moderate the forums, it has to be crooked.

But he is not alone. Another stew known as Ms. PMS is almost as bad as the rev. Helium likes a certain “ass kissing” type for the role of steward. Don’t get me wrong, there are some good people helping out on the site, but they are not aware of the unscrupulous goings-on by the staff. Before being banned I received a phone call from Mark Ranalli concerning the stews getting paid. He claimed to be unaware of the stewards being able to rate and access any channel they desired. Yeah right! After I agreed not to spill the beans about the stewards special privileges until after the new year, I was banned from the site permanently.

No matter what the terms of service were when you joined the site, you have no recourse if they suddenly change the policy. Oh yes, you can stop writing for Helium and lose all of your work, because unless you keep rating forever you receive no pay for your articles. When I joined, the agreement was for Helium to pay a writer for their work as long as the writer was alive. Even after the writer’s demise the writer’s heirs would continue to receive the income from the articles. Presently, the heirs have to participate on Helium by rating articles and keeping a rating star or they receive nothing. “Slick as owl shit“, as my grandpa used to say.

Avoid Being Taken Advantage Of

Once they get your work you are trapped
Once they get your work you are trapped

Don't Get Trapped By This Site

Many writers are trapped at this cruddy site. If they leave, they lose their work. If they stay, they have to contend with the slime balls running the show. I advise anyone writing there to cut your loses. Helium gives no accounting of the page views nor what percent a writer gets from the ads. The whole “trust us” thing is transparently corrupt.

Don’t just take my word for it, look at the home pages for the hunting and camping channels. I usually have at least one article on the front page while receiving nothing in return. I also do not know how many of my 109 articles have been sold as stock content with Helium pocketing the money.

In short, don’t give these people your hard work for nothing. Do not join this site if you are expecting fair treatment or are looking for a future as a writer. I have never dealt with such creeps before in my life. There are more pricks in the Helium.com balloon now than when they stole my articles. Check out past members on the internet and listen to what they say about Helium.com.

I am not writing this just for the hell of it, I’m trying to keep others from falling for the Helium scam. Just remember, they can ban you at any time for any reason, or no reason at all. They also refuse to respond to the Better Business Bureau about the many complaints filed against them. Stay far away from these cretins or they will rip you off. Take it from someone who knows.

Comments

Mit Kroy profile image

Mit Kroy 2 years ago

Mmmmm...Randy, it sounds like these people @#%* in your cornflakes! I had an account there a long time ago, and it seemed alright while they were looking for people to join, then I went back and took a look a couple of years later. They were way to disorganized and as you eluded to, if that was writing, I'd do without it.

Good hub! You drove the stake deep into that vampire.

Keep on hubbing!

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 2 years ago

You got that right, Mit! They are on my $#!7 list for sure. You can't trust them at all. They will eventually quit paying most of their writers and just keep a few to update new subjects. No matter, it's a clunky, dull site anyway!

Thanks for stopping by, I"m always glad to hear from you.

Randy

Marquis profile image

Marquis Level 1 Commenter 2 years ago

Randy is 100% correct here. I also dealt with Helium and would see the negative side effects of that.

Helium and their contests are indeed a joke. They even ban people who are not liberal on many fronts. And unlike Hubpages which accepts any article on any subject, Helium will reject articles, no matter how well they are composed if it does not fit their criteria.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 2 years ago

I appreciate the input, Marquis. If we can keep others from being scammed by the Helium site it will be a satisfying effort.

habee profile image

habee Level 7 Commenter 2 years ago

Come on, Randy, tell us how you really feel! As I've said before, I've been treated okay there, but you were definitely treated unfairly! I guess they think I've died. I would feel better about if they had let you take your articles with you when you were banned.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 2 years ago

Yes, they are still making money from my stuff. There's no telling how many people they have done this to. Even when banned they still list everyone as active members. It's not just their guts I hate.

Marisa Wright profile image

Marisa Wright Level 5 Commenter 2 years ago

Randy, my only concern about this article is that rants aren't taken seriously - people read the anger in your text and think you've just got an axe to grind. That's why I tried to take a calmer approach in my own Hub on the subject.

I can agree with your statement about stewards and kissing ass. I was a steward for a few short weeks, but I was reprimanded for agreeing with someone who posted a (very mild) criticism on the Helium forum. I got told that as a steward, I wasn't allowed to say anything negative about Helium or agree with any criticisms. Needless to say, I resigned.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 2 years ago

You may be correct Marisa, but look at it this way, both approaches are covered. The calm, inside the system, approach you chose, and the axe grinding, tell-it-like-it-is, approach I enjoyed writing about.

It certainly does no harm to make people take a long look at Helium before putting their work on the site. As I stated in my article, I sold some articles there and made a few bucks, but the money was not worth dealing with the cretins.

Thanks for commenting Marisa

darkside profile image

darkside 2 years ago

Randy, I appreciate the warts-and-all expose you've published. Marisa's calmer approach is worth reading, and I too have a rather calm approach in a hub I published about Helium. But your story is needed too. So people can see both the bigger picture and the finer details. It's easy to find 'the good', but I also need to know about 'the bad' and 'the ugly'.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 2 years ago

I really appreciate your comments, Darkside. Believe it or not, I agonized over whether to tell as much as I did simply because of it appearing as merely a rant. But the truth sometimes comes out as a rant if one tells it like it is.

I figured Marisa's version told another side and I did not know you wrote about Helium but will check out your hub.

Thanks again.

Arthur Fontes profile image

Arthur Fontes 2 years ago

I just signed up for Helium but as of yet I have not uploaded anything. Thanks for the warning I would be upset if I lost my content. I will be careful what if anything I upload there.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 2 years ago

I am glad to save you the grief, Arthur. I wish someone had warned me. Thanks for reading!

debugs profile image

debugs 2 years ago

Hey Randy, I know Miss PMS! (lol!) Frankly and objectively, I still think that Barbara Whitlock is NOT bad. I take it as she has a job to do. I don't like the Reverend (bwahhahahaha) there though because he is a certified prick and I know a lot of people who see him as a Reverend who doesn't REALLY belong to ANY legit Church.. I even doubt if the Flying Spaghetti Monster Church would accept that liar.Miss PMS on the other hand is a psycho and "Miss Stars Rachelle" is plain arrogant. She believes she's the greatest writer in the world and the BEST mentor (lol!) to "others". Helium is a scam and by this time, I think everyone is cyberspace knows that.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 2 years ago

Babs snows people, Bugsy! I am slowly getting the whole inside story from many who, just like you and I, found out things the hard way. Some have some very interesting stories to tell too.

Babs and the others know they are not being honest with the writers. Even if they can convince themselves it's for the good of the site, they know it still isn't the truth.

I smell a tell-all expose' sometime in the near future!

Thanks as always, Bugsy!

Randy

Dolorez 23 months ago

Randy, I have been writing and getting paid by Helium.com for over six months now and can totally say your article is right on the money!! For over 200 articles I lose my writing stars every month when it is pay day, then they go back up to 3 writing stars again after pay day. I have documented this because I didn't think they would ever pay me at all. I do get just 25 or so dollars for the 75+ dollars they should be paying. The so called rating system keeps your writing (stars) score at a biased low for them to not have to pay you, they actually tell you that in the payment section that they will take your "writing" stars away at any time they see fit, and they do every month . . . I make sure I do the rating exercise that they give you $3.00 per month for (not per article, but only $3.00 per month) and you do not require any skill at all to rate another persons articles, you just point and click, no one ever knows if you even looked at these articles or not. I fully expect the "cheerleader, stewards" to rebuke this post, because I see that on any neg. web info against Helium, hmmm, we will see. Thanks for a good, clear, honest article, I enjoyed it.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 23 months ago

Thank you for relating your personal experience with Helium, Delores! You are not alone by any stretch of the imagination. The sad thing is that many stews think all criticism is sour grapes, but I clearly indicated I had success both in marketplace sales, contest winnings, and achieving writing and rating stars.

I protested the lies being told by the major players in the Helium conspiracy and it caused me to be banned when they had to admit I was right.

Do not waste your time writing when they are clearly cheating you. You are just one of many whom they manipulate the scores of to keep from paying what they owe. I wish they would protest this article, but they know it is the truth so we will not hear much from them.

Thank you for relating your experiences at Helium and please keep me informed of anything else you think would be helpful!

Randy Godwin

earnestshub profile image

earnestshub Level 2 Commenter 21 months ago

Wow Randy! What a pack of losers! I have never used helium and certainly won't be starting to now!

Great hub mate. Rather than mince words, you have given me a good straight on look at it.

I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole!

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 21 months ago

Thanks for checking it out, Earnest! It was the first writing site Holle and I joined, so we were very naive about the way the site operated.

Holle and Marisa Wright, among others, still have to rate articles there before they will be paid for articles already published. I advise anyone not to write there! They change the TOS when they please!

Paul 16 months ago

The have cancelled $144 in earnings I have with them. I couldn't claim the money initially because they wouldn't do anything but Paypal (and that stopped working for my country). Now, when I want to send it to someone in need, I find that have changed the rules without notice and say it is my fault for not checking. Utter slimeballs.

Is it actually legal for them to receive a license to publish out work and then change the terms of that license unilaterally by changing their site rules? Is there room for a class action for copyright infringement, since the terms under which the content was provided have been broken?

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 16 months ago

They are slimeballs, Paul! I think this covers them. They change the TOS at will and seem to be immune to any legal action, similar to credit card companies.

Massachusetts is one of those states which allows such disreputable companies to locate in their states seemingly without risk of being sued for dirty dealing.

They can boot members at any time and keep everything, including money and articles. Sorry you too got scammed.

Thanks for sharing your experiences with them.

Randy

Denise Calaman 12 months ago

I am a Helium Channel Steward, or rather I guess I am still listed as one but I haven't written for Helium since I was blindsided by the company in November 2010. The channel stewards were given a little more notice that the ax was coming. Although, they merely told us that they were making "changes". Never did I think that my little extra supplemental nest egg would dwindle from $100's each month to nothing. When I emailed Silverstein she basically told me that I was misinformed about how the system was going to work.

MOnths later, the system works exactly like I said it would. And ALOT of writers have left. But not enough, because the site is still operational.

I wrote for Helium for a number of years before I was asked to become a Steward. I have no editing experience but agreed to help out with fertility articles because I struggled with infertility and my sons were born extremely premature. I enjoyed reading articles and helping people and offering encouraging words to people struggling with infertility.

I was devastated when all of a sudden Helium made me feel expendable as I have made them a good deal of money over the years. I hope the site goes down and it goes down hard!!!

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 12 months ago

Thanks for being an honest person, Denise. I too fell for the "trust us" attitude exhibited by the Helium staff. Helium was my first experience with writing for content sites and I didn't want to think they were being dishonest with me.

At the time, Barbara Whitlock was the main go-to person. We went back and forth with emails where she kept avoiding answering a simple question. I knew no one would go to so much trouble to avoid giving a straight answer to such a query unless it was not one they wanted to answer honestly.

I learned a very valuable lesson from the site. Always keep a skeptical eye out with any online writing site. And if they avoid answering hard questions, ask them harder ones! LOL!

I am glad I was banned from Helium, though. I found HubPages, which pays so much better than they ever did. You ought to give it a try, Denise!

Once again, thanks for giving your personal experience with Helium, Denise. It may prevent others from falling into their trap.

Randy Godwin

Marty McGill 12 months ago

Hey Randy, I see Helium is still sticking it to people. I have stayed away for a couple of years since they banned me. Catch me up on what they're doing? I predicted they would eventually stop 90% of outpay because the business model was flawed from the start. I keep waiting for the end to be announced, but they seem to be hanging on.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 12 months ago

Hey Marty, good to hear from you! I lost your email address when my old computer crashed but have been wanting to see how you were doing.

Yep, Helium is slowly going under with some only giving them a few more months to survive. But they still expect the writers to write for almost nothing.

Some of my hubs here have earned close to $100 a month here counting Amazon sales and Adsense clicks and that's for a single article. So I am happy I got booted when I did. I know of some who have made over $6000 per month here, so Helium does indeed suck!

Rex seems to be his same old sad self, but I wonder what he will do when Helium folds. I wish he would try to write here, that would be a gas! LOL!

Contact me through my profile page if you want more info and try writing here if you still have the urge. I'll be glad to help you get started whether you sign up under my referral on my profile page or not!

There are quite a few former Heliumites here with some doing quite well. Glad you commented on my hub too!

Randy

Marty McGill 12 months ago

Hey Randy, I've made a steady payday from eHow over the last 4 years, but they are closing their compensation program this month. They offered me $700.00 for the rights to 20 of my articles, but I'm gonna' pass and start writing somewhere else. I'll email you and you can fill me in.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 12 months ago

I've been reading about eHow from some users now on HP, Marty. Most are taking the money but a few want to keep some of their articles and move them elsewhere.

Please do email me for any info you need!

Randy

Xenonlit profile image

Xenonlit Level 6 Commenter 4 months ago

As of this date, I have to confirm that Helium is a mess. Recent IT screw ups, changing "rules", people with personality issues, lies and other problems have made the place into a hell hole.

I adamantly refuse to recommend Helium at this point for all of the above reasons and for the decline in functionality of the site.

But I will still write there and take their money, which is vastly less disappointing, after three months, than Hub Pages has been.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 4 months ago

We all have different experiences both here and at Helium, Xenonlit. Some will never make it here with their type of writing and would do better to stick with such places as Helium, or Yahoo! for that matter.

But even if one isn't happy here they can always remove their work and place it elsewhere. Try this at Helium and see where you get.

Randy SSSSS

Marty McGill 3 months ago

Good point about taking your articles elsewhere, Randy. I have a couple hundred articles making Helium money of which I will never receive a dime.

The place is a joke, and the best thing about being banned from Helium is being far away from those losers. One of the dumbest things I've done so far was write for those clowns.

Randy Godwin profile image

Randy Godwin Hub Author 3 months ago

Wow! Good to hear from you Marty! There are several folks here who used to write at Helium and are so glad they don't anymore. Most have had similar experiences to what you and I had there. Rex is still a d**khead as always! LOL!

I hope you are writing elsewhere these days and wish you would try this place out. Thanks for stopping by and don't be a stranger.

You were a great help in exposing the crooks at Helium for their corruption and lies. I won't forget that, I promise! If you ever talk to Jane give her my regards too!

Randy SSSSS

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working